SS Samkey

/back

 

Picture owned by Fred Honisett please ask permission before use at:    fred.honisett@btinternet.com

 

 Fred Honisett (PWSTS 1943) 1948
 Bob Trimnell (Trim) 1948

 William Cullem

 George Mc Alan (see below) 1948
 Ernest Rowe  Able Seaman left Dec 1947
 Chas Plows 16.03.46 to 22.01.47

Dedicated to the memory of the crew of the Steamship Samkey missing at sea the 31st January 1948

CA Cremin

LE Ambrose

GB Chambers

KD Simpson

DM Gee

ES Harradine

WM Wiseman

FC West

FFB Tanner

K Kennedy

AJ MacKenzie

RR Grogan

H Garnett

A Finlayson

RE Hides

JW Gates

PH Colborn

WF Ballard

PCE Mahood

GR Kirby

G McAllan

JJ Martinson

TC Barry

EP MacKenzie

HC Laing

RN Cleland

KT Sparks

DTH Hill

AW Cooper

J Donnachie

J Beggs

AR Holman

WHA Baxter

HM Savill

JW Butler

WE Bouchard

EN White

TJ Sheville

HJ Longdon

RC Hart

RJ Goddard

R Strong

GA Butterworth

 

This memorial window was originally in the chapel of The Missions to Seamen, Victoria Dock Road, London E16

The remnant of the memorial window was moved to All Hallows in 1975, together with its plaque listing
the names of the crew members who were lost at sea.

Download wreck report (pdf file)
 

Courtesy of Mark TraynorCourtesy of Mark TraynorCourtesy of Mark Traynor
 

Courtesy of Mark Traynor


The names of the 43 crew who perished on the SS Samkey in 1948, courtesy of Billy McGee

AMBROSE, 1st Mate, LESLIE ERNEST age 35

BALLARD, SOS, WILLIAM FRANK age 24

BARRY, Chief Engineer, THOMAS CHARLES age 59

BAXTER, Fireman, WILLIAM HAROLD ALFRED age 21

BEGGS, Donkeyman, JAMES age 33

BOUCHARD, Chief Steward, WILLIAM EDWARD age 37

BUTLER, Fireman, JOHN WALTER age 23

BUTTERWORTH, Galley Boy, GEORGE ARTHUR age 17

CHAMBERS, 2nd Mate, GORDON BUXTON age 23

CLELAND, 4th Engineer, ROBERT NORMAN age 25

COLBORN, SOS, PATRICK HARRY age 20

COOPER, Donkeyman, ALFRED WILLIAM age 36

CREMIN, Master, CYRIL AUGUSTINE age 43

DONNACHIE, Donkeyman, JOHN age 26

FINLAYSON, EDH, ALEXANDER age 35

GARNETT, Able Seaman, HARRY age 24

GATES, SOS, JOHN WILLIAM age 20

GEE, 4th Mate, DONALD MICHAEL age 20

GODDARD, Steward, RONALD JOHN age 19

GROGAN, Able Seaman, REGINALD ROSE age 21

HARRADINE, Radio Officer, ERNEST SIDNEY age 22

HARTY, Steward, REGINALD CHARLES age 21

HIDES, EDH, RICHARD EDWARD age 20

HILL, Donkeyman DAVID THOMAS HENRY age 46

HOLMAN, Fireman, ALBERT REES age 21

KENNEDY, Able Seaman, KENNETH. Age 35

KIRKBY, JOS, GEORGE RICHARD age 17

LAING, 3rd Engineer, HENRY CLARENCE age 27

LANGDON, 2nd Cook, HARRY JOHN age 21

McALLAN, JOS, GEORGE age 19

MACKENZIE, Able Seaman, ALLAN JOHN age 20

MACKENZIE, 2nd Engineer EDWARD PATTERSON age 26

MAHOOD, JOS, PETER CHARLES EDWARD age 19

MARTINSON, Deck Boy, JOHN JAMES age 16

SPARKS, Junior Engineer, KENNETH TREVOR age 23

SAVILL, Fireman, HUGH MALCOLM age 34

SHEVILLE, Chief Cook, THOMAS JENKINS age 33

SIMPSON, 3rd Mate, KENNETH DUNCAN age 21

STRONG, Stewards Boy, RAYMOND age 17

TANNER, Able Seaman, FREDERICK CHARLES BERNARD age 26

WEST, Bosun, FREDERICK CHARLES age 31

WHITE, 2nd Steward, ERIC NORMAN age 21

WISEMAN, Carpenter, WILLIAM McPHERSON age 31

Courtesy of Mark Traynor

painting of the Samkey by John Chapman
Painting of the Samkey by John Chapman

● Looking for my friend's name who was a crew member of the Samkey. Ray Strong who like me got a job aboard her before she sailed. However, my father would not let me sail with her saying I was to young. I believe that Ray went down with her. After all these years I keep wondering if this were the case. We were blitz kids living in London during the 39 /45 war and we just needed to get away. We were school pals.
Jack Martin

● My uncle, George Mc Alan (George Noel Rangi Henderson), went down with her in 1948. Mark Traynor

● Please add me to your list that is seeking information about the Samkey and her crew. In particular George Mcallan also know as George Henderson. Before signing on the Samkey I believe he was on the ship the Orari which I believe was in dry dock so it was just a short trip that he signed on for as he would pick up the Orari when he returned, appreciate any information. Shirley Traynor

My Uncle died when the SS Samkey sank in 1948.  His name was David Michael Gee and I believe he was the Radio Officer. Chris Gee

● My name is Chas Plows and I served on the Samkey from 16/3/1946 to 22/01/1947 and we had a pretty hairy storm one time my mate Eric Dove was on the wheel at the time and had to let go and hold on to the pole that went up to the monkey island. We almost capsized I believe that I had to change my pants!! I signed to go back on but my farther died suddenly in Germany and I came out on compassionate grounds and of course the rest is history. Jock the ships chippy got drunk at sea so he got a black discharge and had to come off how lucky was we !!! Chas Plows

● My Uncle and two other lads from the Isle of Lewis were lost on the SS Samkey. They were Allan John Mackenzie, Kenneth Kennedy, Alistair Finlayson. Although the boat sank on Jan 31st 1948 it was not reported in the Stornoway Gazette until Friday November 26th 1948. Donald Mackenzie
 

The `Samkey` vanished without a trace in a mid Atlantic storm on January 31st 1948

Also in the same area on the same date an aircraft `Star Tiger` (Tudor IV) vanished without trace with 31 people onboard.

The total crew of the `Samkey` was 43. No trace has ever been found of either. The `Samkey` was an American built Liberty ship of 7,219 tonnes, on charter to the New Zealand Shipping Company. The `Samkey` was bound for Cuba from London in ballast, her destination was to have been Tunaz de Zaza in Cuba. The last heard of the ship was a radio message asking for a weather report at noon on January 31st. Reported to Horta radio in a position Latitude 41 48 N., Longitude 24 00 W. Azores Radio had news of her, and another vessel heard her. It was the night of one of the worst mid-Atlantic storms with waves over 800 feet long and 50 feet high.

A Court of Enquiry was held on July 23rd 1948, which lasted 4 days it was stated -“here was a well built ship efficiently manned and surveyed immediately before the voyage, which on or after January 31 this year was overwhelmed by something that was so sudden in its onslaught and so dire in its effect, that no signal of any kind was made from her, and she just vanished from sight”. Weather charts indicated winds of over 75 m.p.h.

It was also reported that an air and sea search had been made-four ships had been diverted for the purpose-and no trace of wreckage was found.

Curiously, two of the `Samkey's sister ships had been lost within the preceding twelve months - the `Samtampa` wrecked near Porthcrawl in April 1947 and the `Samwater` caught fire off Portugal in January 1947.

The `Samkey` was built at the Bethlehem Shipyards in Baltimore U.S.A. The above water colour picture was commissioned by FREDERICK JOHN HONISETT (PWSTS 1943) who was an Able-seaman onboard the previous voyage to the ill-fated one, who left the ship on December 29th. 1947, one month earlier, having just completed an 11 month trip on her.

The voyage previously : London England to Halifax Nova Scotia Canada, to Curacao West Indies, through the Panama Canal to Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Newcastle Australia, then on charter to Makatea in the South Pacific Seas to load phosphates, for Auckland New Zealand. This trip was made back and forwards several times. On the first trip to Makatea. we went to the aid of a three-masted schooner `OISEAU-DES-ILES` which struck a reef at Mopelia Island 300 miles west of Tahiti, onboard the `Oiseau-des-Iles` were 140 male workers from Rarotonga travelling to the phosphate works in Makatea. The `Samkey` under the command of Captain J.J. Youngs O.B.E. D.S.C. R.N.R. (who incidentally was in command of the `Mulberry Harbour` in the invasion of France 1944) went to the aid of the schooner at the request of the governor of Tahiti. Also onboard the schooner was a French recruiting officer, and an elderly American woman. The schooner struck the reef only a few yards from where the German raider `SEEADLER` under Count Felix von Luckner was wrecked in 1917, parts of the raider could still be seen lying near the schooner. Although water was pouring into the schooner faster than being pumped out, Capt. Youngs offered to lend two of our pumps provided his ship towed the damaged vessel to Makatea. The French Captain refused to abandon ship and the offer was declined when he heard that two pumps were were being brought out from Tahiti the following day, and the schooner was towed by a rescue schooner which brought the pumps out.

The male workers and the French Officer were taken onboard the `Samkey` sleeping space was allotted below decks, They were taken to Tahiti by the `Samkey` which arrived in time for `Bastille Day` and all the celebrations that went with it, much to our crews delight. A time to remember.

On route to Makatea and New Zealand we called at New Plymouth, Wellington, Auckland, and Napier. The voyage lasted 11 months docking in London on Monday December 29th 1947.
 
There was a memorial window to the ship and the crew, in the Mariners Chapel of St. Andrew, Victoria Dock Road, also a memorial book with the crews names inside. The chapel has since been demolished , during which the window was broken. Part of the window is in the church of `All Hallows by the Tower` on Tower Hill opposite the Tower of London, where there is also a plaque with the 43 members of the crew named, but no whereabouts of where the memorial book is now.

The sister ship to the `Samkey` S.S. Leicester which Fred Honisett joined next for a six month voyage to New Zealand, which ended in August 1948, one month later in September 1948, the `Leicester` was abandoned and six lives were lost, one of which was the replacement for Fred Honisett. The `Leicester` was eventually towed to Bermuda.

During 1948, the following were recorded-
March 5th. `AL SNYDER` Cabin cruiser & Skiff found abandoned 3 crew missing.
April 1948 `WILD GOOSE` (vessel in tow ) 4 onboard.
December 28th. DC3 passenger plane 35 onboard.
On January 17th. 1949 A year after the airliner `Star Tiger` was missing with the `Samkey`. The `STAR ARIEL` sister ship to the `Star Tiger` went missing 20 onboard.

Note: Apart from war casualties, the disappearance, without trace, of an ocean going liner is an exceedingly rare event. The case of the `Anglo Australian` appears to be the last one which can be compared with the `Samkey` This was a vessel of 5,456 tons gross, and was posted missing on May 1938. She was thus on a voyage leading through the same waters as that of the `Samkey` and was not heard of again after passing Fayal on March 14th. 1938 . “Lloyds List.”

Courtesy of Mark Traynor

model of the ship St Albans built by Bob Emmett - the same type of ship as the Samkey

Samkey courtesy of John Chapman

The above photo was taken in Brissy in the ships wartime colours ie grey all
 over including emergency rafts adjacent to the masts Port and Starboard.

Nov 2011 - My name is Edward Barnett my brother Ronald John Goddard was one of the crew who perished when SS Samkey was lost 31 January 1948. As a lad of nine I accompanied our Mother to the initial memorial service held 16 April 1948 at the Seaman's Mission Victoria Dock Road, at the reception there was a couple of young schoolgirls who represented a school that adopted the Samkey and had wrote to the crew before the tragedy, do wish that I could find name of that school so as to pass on much belated thanks.

Can anyone assist Edward?

 

The PWSTS is grateful to Mark Traynor for the construction of this page